Sample Contract Review
Based on a real anonymised employment contract — this is exactly what you'll receive
Your real review appears on screen in English.
Section 1: Overview
This is a permanent, full-time employment contract between a Dublin-based main contractor and a Site Engineer, effective from a stated start date. Headline terms: base salary €48,000, 6-month probationary period, standard 39-hour working week, and a 1-month notice period on both sides after probation. As a Site Engineer role, this sits outside the Sectoral Employment Order for Construction — the SEO applies to site-based trades and operatives, not engineering/design-office roles, so SEO minimum rates aren't the relevant benchmark here; general market data is. Overall, this reads as a broadly standard Irish construction employment contract — most core terms are reasonable and typical for the sector, but there are a handful of areas genuinely worth understanding clearly before signing: the notice period during probation, a fairly broad confidentiality clause, a discretionary bonus with no defined criteria, and no mention of site travel or subsistence for multi-site work.
Section 2: Clause-by-Clause Analysis
✅ FAIR — Salary and payment: €48,000 paid monthly, reviewed annually. Standard structure, nothing unusual.
✅ FAIR — Hours of work: 39 hours/week, core site hours stated clearly. In line with standard Irish construction practice.
⚠️ WATCH OUT — Probation notice: during the 6-month probation period, the employer can terminate with just 1 week's notice, while you're required to give 2 weeks. Most Irish contracts at this level use equal notice on both sides even during probation — this asymmetry is worth being aware of, though not unusual enough to be a dealbreaker on its own.
✅ FAIR — Annual leave: 21 days plus public holidays, one day above the Irish statutory minimum of 20 days.
✅ FAIR — Sick pay: statutory Illness Benefit scheme referenced correctly, no employer top-up promised or implied. Standard for this level.
⚠️ WATCH OUT — Confidentiality clause: the wording covers "all information relating to the Company's business" with no time limit after employment ends. This is broader than typical — most Irish contracts specify a reasonable duration (e.g. 12–24 months post-employment) rather than an indefinite scope. Worth asking whether this can be time-bound.
✅ FAIR — Pension: 5% employer contribution after 6 months' service, in line with sector norms.
✅ FAIR — Intellectual property: work product created during employment (drawings, designs, site documentation) belongs to the employer. Standard for an employed engineering role — this would only be worth questioning on a contractor/freelance basis.
⚠️ WATCH OUT — Bonus: described as "discretionary, subject to company performance" with no criteria, target, or typical range given. Legally this means the employer owes you nothing regardless of your own performance — worth asking what "discretionary" has actually meant in practice for people in this role historically.
⚠️ WATCH OUT — Site allowance / travel: no clause addressing travel time, mileage, or subsistence for work at sites other than the primary location named in the contract. For a Site Engineer, this is a real gap — multi-site movement is common in this role, and its absence here means it would default to unpaid unless separately agreed. Worth raising directly before signing.
✅ FAIR — Tools and PPE: employer confirms PPE is provided free of charge, in line with Irish health & safety law. No tool allowance mentioned, but none is required for this role.
⚠️ WATCH OUT — Safe Pass: stated as "the employee's responsibility to maintain a valid Safe Pass at all times," with no clause on what happens if it lapses (e.g. unpaid site-access suspension vs disciplinary action). Worth clarifying what the actual consequence looks like in practice.
🚩 RED FLAG — Non-compete: a 12-month non-compete clause covering "any construction business operating in the Republic of Ireland" — this is unusually broad in geography (nationwide, not local) and would be very difficult for the employer to actually enforce under Irish law, but it could still create anxiety or hesitation when considering your next move. Worth raising directly, or having a solicitor review this specific clause.
✅ FAIR — Governing law and jurisdiction: Republic of Ireland courts, as expected for an Irish-based role.
Section 3: The Three Things to Pay Most Attention To
1. The non-compete clause is the single biggest item here — its geographic scope (nationwide) makes it unlikely to hold up if ever tested, but it's still worth a direct conversation with the employer or a quick solicitor check before you sign, purely for your own peace of mind.
2. The missing site allowance/travel clause is a genuinely practical gap for a Site Engineer specifically — ask directly how travel to secondary sites is handled before you need the answer, not after.
3. The discretionary bonus and the confidentiality clause's lack of a time limit are both smaller points individually, but worth raising together in the same conversation — ask what "discretionary" has meant in practice, and whether confidentiality can be bound to a reasonable period after you leave.
Section 4: Plain English Summary
Overall, this is a reasonably standard Irish construction employment contract — the core terms (salary, hours, annual leave, pension, sick pay) are all fair and typical for a Site Engineer role in Dublin. You should feel comfortable signing the majority of this as-is. The things worth raising before you sign, roughly in order of importance: the scope of the non-compete clause, how site travel is actually handled day-to-day, what the discretionary bonus has meant historically, and whether the confidentiality clause can be time-bound. None of these is a reason to walk away from the offer, but together they're worth a genuine 10-minute conversation with HR before you put your name on it — not a rubber-stamp signature.
This review identifies clauses that appear unusual or one-sided based on Irish market norms. It is not a legal opinion and does not replace advice from a qualified Irish employment solicitor.